madbeanpedals::forum

General => Open Discussion => Topic started by: jubal81 on February 11, 2014, 01:52:54 AM

Title: Only 88%
Post by: jubal81 on February 11, 2014, 01:52:54 AM


New Study Finds Only 88% Of Guitar Center Customers Become Famous Musicians (http://www.theonion.com/articles/new-study-finds-only-88-of-guitar-center-customers,35227/)
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: RobA on February 11, 2014, 02:02:08 AM
Damn, I knew a needed to buy the more expensive strings.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: jubal81 on February 11, 2014, 02:20:12 AM
Actually, I just thought back and realized I've never actually been in a Guitar Center. Ordered a used pedal online once, but that's it.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: RobA on February 11, 2014, 02:50:57 AM
I've been in four of them around where I live and from that experience, I hate going in them. I really dislike stores that cover the windows and block out the world and all of the GC's I've been in are like that. They have a very similar feeling to Best Buys to me and that's not something I like mixing with my experience of anything music related. I can't say that I think you've missed anything.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: pickdropper on February 11, 2014, 03:06:55 AM
I work really close to one, but rarely set foot in it.  I guess i won't bother now that I know that there's a 12% chance that it won't result in me being a famous musician.  I guess I'll have to think about those expensive strings.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: billstein on February 11, 2014, 03:17:44 AM
This explains why I'm not a famous musician. I've been in GC so many times, I never had a chance.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: selfdestroyer on February 11, 2014, 03:26:32 AM
what... What.. WHAT! I can't hear you cause that kid that cant play a damn thing with out buzzing and dead fretting and needs to be on 11 for some ungodly reason and no employee cares.

I usually hide in the keyboard and drum machine section and bang on some pads.

And why is NOTHING ever in tune there. There is a smaller local shop that the people go around and tune stuff every few hours. I hate picking up something and having to spend 5 minutes tuning.. and remember, you can't hear a damn thing.

/rant
Cody
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: jimilee on February 11, 2014, 03:30:58 AM
I call shenanigans. I don't like going in there, usually end up educating them about what it is I am looking for. What's an sm48? sheesh!
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: pickdropper on February 11, 2014, 03:33:54 AM
A couple of years ago, I went in there to grab strings (admittedly the normal kind) and there was a kid just wailing a 3 chord Blink 182 tune over and over and over.  I asked the clerk behind the desk how he could put up with that all day.  He looked at me stone faced and said "What do you mean?"

Those guys must have rock solid self defense mechanisms in place.  Either that or he REALLY likes Blink 182.   ;D
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: chromesphere on February 11, 2014, 03:34:50 AM
Its funny, every country has their version of Guitar Center.  Im just replacing the words "guitar center" with "billy hydes" and it all makes sense :D
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 04:48:51 AM
I was in Guitar Center on Sunday to buy patch cables.  I much prefer buying from small independent shops.  However, often don't have good selection of small odds & ends, and they aren't open on Sunday.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: blearyeyes on February 11, 2014, 07:25:04 AM
I tried to get a job there...hmm 40 years audio engineering, guitar player forever, managed a local music store for several years, pro audio salesman for a long time...Sorry! Ended up as a Forensic Audio Video Examiner. Not dumb enough for GC.. I hate that place too!
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: flanagan0718 on February 11, 2014, 02:32:15 PM
I worked at the local competitor chain (Daddy's Junky Music) in NH. There are 3 Guitar Centers within 30 min of my house and still refuse to go there. A while ago (last year) I went to GC to trade in some Cymbal stands and they offered me $10 a piece for my like new $150 Tama Road pro stands. I laughed in the kid's face and told him to get bent. 2 weeks later the manager emailed me and offered me $50 each store credit and i turned it down and told him i would never shop there again. I still have not set foot in there. That place is a joke, It's the K-Mart of Music stores. +1 for the "mom and pops' places!
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: Willybomb on February 11, 2014, 02:36:35 PM
QuoteIm just replacing the words "guitar center" with "billy hydes" and it all makes sense
Well, we don't have to worry about that any more, eh?
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 03:04:35 PM
Quote from: flanagan0718 on February 11, 2014, 02:32:15 PM
I worked at the local competitor chain (Daddy's Junky Music) in NH. There are 3 Guitar Centers within 30 min of my house and still refuse to go there. A while ago (last year) I went to GC to trade in some Cymbal stands and they offered me $10 a piece for my like new $150 Tama Road pro stands. I laughed in the kid's face and told him to get bent. 2 weeks later the manager emailed me and offered me $50 each store credit and i turned it down and told him i would never shop there again. I still have not set foot in there. That place is a joke, It's the K-Mart of Music stores. +1 for the "mom and pops' places!

I understand your position.  I can clarify that I dislike the chain (in general I don't like what large chains have done to local business people), but happen to like the manager and some of the employees of the closest GC to me (Danvers, MA).  They all seem to be local musicians trying to cover expenses with a day job.

My late son got the drum kit of his dreams for his Make-A-Wish - a very high-end DW kit with a ton of Zildjian cymbals and hard storage/transport cases.  I'm not sure I ever discussed Steve on this forum, he died of cancer at the age of 15 - his 10th anniversary is this Friday, the 14th.

About 15 months ago I finally decided to do something with the kit.  At first I couldn't decide whether to donate it to a school or charity, or sell it and donate the cash.  One of my investigative stops was to the drum department of GC to see if they could help me figure out what it was worth.  I was VERY clear that I was leaning towards donating it rather than selling it, but knowing the value would help me decide.  An employee there spent about 2 hours researching every component of the set, found the wholesale & current retail values, and gave me a detailed list with both.  During this process he got the drum department manager and the store manager involved.  Both made it clear that there were no strings attached to the time they put into this, and that they would buy any or all components at the wholesale price they provided.  I was really moved by their help.  They even suggested a charity that might be interested in taking the set.  So clearly I have mixed feelings.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: flanagan0718 on February 11, 2014, 03:22:25 PM
Quote from: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 03:04:35 PM
Quote from: flanagan0718 on February 11, 2014, 02:32:15 PM
I worked at the local competitor chain (Daddy's Junky Music) in NH. There are 3 Guitar Centers within 30 min of my house and still refuse to go there. A while ago (last year) I went to GC to trade in some Cymbal stands and they offered me $10 a piece for my like new $150 Tama Road pro stands. I laughed in the kid's face and told him to get bent. 2 weeks later the manager emailed me and offered me $50 each store credit and i turned it down and told him i would never shop there again. I still have not set foot in there. That place is a joke, It's the K-Mart of Music stores. +1 for the "mom and pops' places!

I understand your position.  I can clarify that I dislike the chain (in general I don't like what large chains have done to local business people), but happen to like the manager and some of the employees of the closest GC to me (Danvers, MA).  They all seem to be local musicians trying to cover expenses with a day job.

My late son got the drum kit of his dreams for his Make-A-Wish - a very high-end DW kit with a ton of Zildjian cymbals and hard storage/transport cases.  I'm not sure I ever discussed Steve on this forum, he died of cancer at the age of 15 - his 10th anniversary is this Friday, the 14th.

About 15 months ago I finally decided to do something with the kit.  At first I couldn't decide whether to donate it to a school or charity, or sell it and donate the cash.  One of my investigative stops was to the drum department of GC to see if they could help me figure out what it was worth.  I was VERY clear that I was leaning towards donating it rather than selling it, but knowing the value would help me decide.  An employee there spent about 2 hours researching every component of the set, found the wholesale & current retail values, and gave me a detailed list with both.  During this process he got the drum department manager and the store manager involved.  Both made it clear that there were no strings attached to the time they put into this, and that they would buy any or all components at the wholesale price they provided.  I was really moved by their help.  They even suggested a charity that might be interested in taking the set.  So clearly I have mixed feelings.

I used to know a bunch of those dudes! Bob (I think he now works in Portsmouth)was the manager of the Daddy's in Peabody on RT 1. I worked with him a few times at the RT 1 store. Not all of the employees are mindless, Most of the ones in Nashua NH are my old Customers from Daddys and Johny Friday is actually my old bassist. But That being said I still have a HUGE issue with the way they handle their customers and used gear.
p.s. sorry to hear about your son. My wife and I are having a baby in May and I don't know what i would do if that happened. You are officially one GREATS in my book. Cheers!
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: jkokura on February 11, 2014, 03:45:42 PM
The Canadian equivalent is Long and McQuade, which on a whole isn't as bad as GC, but isn't the best option. However, too often they're the only option. They have a massive expansion plan on right now, and they've bought out several smaller chains in the last decade and essentially 'replaced' the stores with they're own. They want to be the GC of Canada I guess.

The nice thing is that they've set a standard in pricing. You can pretty much go into any other shop and say, "this is what L&M sell it for," and most places price match.

The best shop I've ever been to in Canada is my local one, Fuzztone. Guys in there are awesome, it's a small time shop, they do enormous business in the area, and their prices are realistic. As much as I like supporting Mom and Pop shops, I hate walking in and seeing guitars listed at MSRP prices. I can only imagine how many Moms and Dads out there have been taken for hundreds or thousands in extra money because they didn't do a little research.

Jacob
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 09:14:08 PM
Quote from: flanagan0718 on February 11, 2014, 03:22:25 PM
I used to know a bunch of those dudes! Bob (I think he now works in Portsmouth)was the manager of the Daddy's in Peabody on RT 1. I worked with him a few times at the RT 1 store. Not all of the employees are mindless, Most of the ones in Nashua NH are my old Customers from Daddys and Johny Friday is actually my old bassist. But That being said I still have a HUGE issue with the way they handle their customers and used gear.
p.s. sorry to hear about your son. My wife and I are having a baby in May and I don't know what i would do if that happened. You are officially one GREATS in my book. Cheers!

What's your problem with used gear?  I have a friend who shops at the Natick MA store & buys lots of used gear.  They seem to be pretty lenient about returns.  He went through 3-4 amps before he settled on one.  Used them in rehearsal to see how they fit with the band.

BTW, I miss Daddy's.  I loved going to their Peabody store on Rt. 1 south.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: jkokura on February 11, 2014, 09:28:05 PM
I think he's referring to people who bring them used gear. Most shops won't give the true value of a used instrument. Which makes sense, because they have to/should make a profit on selling used gear.

Jacob
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: GermanCdn on February 11, 2014, 09:39:36 PM
Quote from: jkokura on February 11, 2014, 03:45:42 PM
The Canadian equivalent is Long and McQuade, which on a whole isn't as bad as GC, but isn't the best option. However, too often they're the only option. They have a massive expansion plan on right now, and they've bought out several smaller chains in the last decade and essentially 'replaced' the stores with they're own. They want to be the GC of Canada I guess.

The nice thing is that they've set a standard in pricing. You can pretty much go into any other shop and say, "this is what L&M sell it for," and most places price match.

The best shop I've ever been to in Canada is my local one, Fuzztone. Guys in there are awesome, it's a small time shop, they do enormous business in the area, and their prices are realistic. As much as I like supporting Mom and Pop shops, I hate walking in and seeing guitars listed at MSRP prices. I can only imagine how many Moms and Dads out there have been taken for hundreds or thousands in extra money because they didn't do a little research.

Jacob

No hating on L&M allowed, they're like Cheers for me, and I am in fact Norm.  I walk in, they guide me to the crack they know I crave, and smile as I walk out the door, lol.

Actually, truthfully, L&M are a lot better than Guitar Center in my experience.  Generally the guys are far more knowledgeable, though I do refuse to shop at one of the ones here in town (fortunately, it's the lousiest one) because one employee felt the need to ream me out after I helped a guy out that he clearly was not.  Of course, I then proceeded to call his boss by name over, had them pull up my account, and told him if he valued my continued business, he'd turf the prick.  He did, but hired him back a couple of months later, so I don't shop there, but I digress.

One thing I dislike about GC is their propensity to put used gear on the floor before it's cleared the sell after date (for serial number checks to make sure they're not stolen).  The one I frequent in Spokane regularly has gear that I would in fact buy (I only buy used) were it available, but don't tease me by putting it out then tell me I can't take it home.

As far as pricing on used gear, you will always lose money trading in/selling gear to a big chain store.  L&M gives you 70% of what they will sell it for, which is reasonable, but completely arbitrary when it comes to sellling point.  Point in case, I picked up a mint 2012 American Standard Strat used for $700, which means they gave the guy who sold it $490 for it, after selling it to him less than a year earlier for $1100.  There was one right beside it on the wall, same year, same fretboard, same finish, same condition, selling for $950, so some other dude got $200 more for the same guitar.  Completely arbitrary.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: chromesphere on February 11, 2014, 09:52:36 PM
Quote from: Willybomb on February 11, 2014, 02:36:35 PM
QuoteIm just replacing the words "guitar center" with "billy hydes" and it all makes sense
Well, we don't have to worry about that any more, eh?

They've reopened :)
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: chromesphere on February 11, 2014, 10:04:30 PM
Quote from: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 03:04:35 PM
My late son got the drum kit of his dreams for his Make-A-Wish - a very high-end DW kit with a ton of Zildjian cymbals and hard storage/transport cases.  I'm not sure I ever discussed Steve on this forum, he died of cancer at the age of 15 - his 10th anniversary is this Friday, the 14th.

Gee's Bob...sorry to pull this one part of your post out, it just pulled at my heart strings.  As a father my heart goes out to you mate.  Condolences...
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: GrindCustoms on February 11, 2014, 10:15:49 PM
Vive le Québec!

We don't have any chain music store here.... well not that i know, only independants.

In most place you just need to tell them that you can have it on the internet for a X price, show them the link and they'll match.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: GermanCdn on February 11, 2014, 10:25:48 PM
Quote from: GrindCustoms on February 11, 2014, 10:15:49 PM
Vive le Québec!

We don't have any chain music store here.... well not that i know, only independants.

In most place you just need to tell them that you can have it on the internet for a X price, show them the link and they'll match.

You've got Steve's Music, which qualifies as a chain as they have outlets in Quebec and Ontario, though I suspect they are next on the L&M buyout plan.  There are a couple of nice boutique stores in Montreal, though for the life of me I can't remember their names.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: gtr2 on February 11, 2014, 10:37:36 PM
Quote from: chromesphere on February 11, 2014, 10:04:30 PM
Quote from: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 03:04:35 PM
My late son got the drum kit of his dreams for his Make-A-Wish - a very high-end DW kit with a ton of Zildjian cymbals and hard storage/transport cases.  I'm not sure I ever discussed Steve on this forum, he died of cancer at the age of 15 - his 10th anniversary is this Friday, the 14th.

Gee's Bob...sorry to pull this one part of your post out, it just pulled at my heart strings.  As a father my heart goes out to you mate.  Condolences...

THIS^
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 10:46:23 PM
Quote from: chromesphere on February 11, 2014, 10:04:30 PM
Gee's Bob...sorry to pull this one part of your post out, it just pulled at my heart strings.  As a father my heart goes out to you mate.  Condolences...

Paul, I appreciate your comment, and Flanagan's, and the PMs I received.  I hesitated to mention Steve, experience tells me that it can be a conversation stopper...

That being said, 10 years out Barb and I miss him every day.  But we are lucky - we had a daughter to keep on track, and we were the beneficiaries of excellent psychological care as a family.  So we found positive things to focus on and positive ways to keep Steve's memory alive.  We have to work every day to keep on track, but being a parent never ends anyway, under any circumstances.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: GrindCustoms on February 11, 2014, 11:34:13 PM
Quote from: GermanCdn on February 11, 2014, 10:25:48 PM
Quote from: GrindCustoms on February 11, 2014, 10:15:49 PM
Vive le Québec!

We don't have any chain music store here.... well not that i know, only independants.

In most place you just need to tell them that you can have it on the internet for a X price, show them the link and they'll match.

You've got Steve's Music, which qualifies as a chain as they have outlets in Quebec and Ontario, though I suspect they are next on the L&M buyout plan.  There are a couple of nice boutique stores in Montreal, though for the life of me I can't remember their names.

True, Steve's has stores in Montreal, Toronto and Ottawa iirc.

In MTL the coolest pedal store is MoogAudio... can't really go wrong with a name like that.

I agree that there's couple owners that have couple stores, up to 5 at max... but i would'nt call that a chain... just an expansion. For me chain is really like LongMcQuade having a store in every city that have more than 100 000 citizens.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: pickdropper on February 12, 2014, 12:06:05 AM

Quote from: gtr2 on February 11, 2014, 10:37:36 PM
Quote from: chromesphere on February 11, 2014, 10:04:30 PM
Quote from: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 03:04:35 PM
My late son got the drum kit of his dreams for his Make-A-Wish - a very high-end DW kit with a ton of Zildjian cymbals and hard storage/transport cases.  I'm not sure I ever discussed Steve on this forum, he died of cancer at the age of 15 - his 10th anniversary is this Friday, the 14th.

Gee's Bob...sorry to pull this one part of your post out, it just pulled at my heart strings.  As a father my heart goes out to you mate.  Condolences...

THIS^

Yeah.  It's hard to apply the appropriate words for that kind of loss.  As a father, I can't imagine it. 
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: chromesphere on February 12, 2014, 12:18:24 AM
Quote from: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 10:46:23 PM
Quote from: chromesphere on February 11, 2014, 10:04:30 PM
Gee's Bob...sorry to pull this one part of your post out, it just pulled at my heart strings.  As a father my heart goes out to you mate.  Condolences...

Paul, I appreciate your comment, and Flanagan's, and the PMs I received.  I hesitated to mention Steve, experience tells me that it can be a conversation stopper...

That being said, 10 years out Barb and I miss him every day.  But we are lucky - we had a daughter to keep on track, and we were the beneficiaries of excellent psychological care as a family.  So we found positive things to focus on and positive ways to keep Steve's memory alive.  We have to work every day to keep on track, but being a parent never ends anyway, under any circumstances.

No parent should lose their child...its just something I think you don't 'get' until you have a child of your own...wishing you the best mate.
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: wgc on February 12, 2014, 03:43:10 AM
+1
Title: Re: Only 88%
Post by: Leevibe on February 12, 2014, 05:52:18 AM
Quote from: bcalla on February 11, 2014, 03:04:35 PM
Quote from: flanagan0718 on February 11, 2014, 02:32:15 PM
I worked at the local competitor chain (Daddy's Junky Music) in NH. There are 3 Guitar Centers within 30 min of my house and still refuse to go there. A while ago (last year) I went to GC to trade in some Cymbal stands and they offered me $10 a piece for my like new $150 Tama Road pro stands. I laughed in the kid's face and told him to get bent. 2 weeks later the manager emailed me and offered me $50 each store credit and i turned it down and told him i would never shop there again. I still have not set foot in there. That place is a joke, It's the K-Mart of Music stores. +1 for the "mom and pops' places!

I understand your position.  I can clarify that I dislike the chain (in general I don't like what large chains have done to local business people), but happen to like the manager and some of the employees of the closest GC to me (Danvers, MA).  They all seem to be local musicians trying to cover expenses with a day job.

My late son got the drum kit of his dreams for his Make-A-Wish - a very high-end DW kit with a ton of Zildjian cymbals and hard storage/transport cases.  I'm not sure I ever discussed Steve on this forum, he died of cancer at the age of 15 - his 10th anniversary is this Friday, the 14th.

About 15 months ago I finally decided to do something with the kit.  At first I couldn't decide whether to donate it to a school or charity, or sell it and donate the cash.  One of my investigative stops was to the drum department of GC to see if they could help me figure out what it was worth.  I was VERY clear that I was leaning towards donating it rather than selling it, but knowing the value would help me decide.  An employee there spent about 2 hours researching every component of the set, found the wholesale & current retail values, and gave me a detailed list with both.  During this process he got the drum department manager and the store manager involved.  Both made it clear that there were no strings attached to the time they put into this, and that they would buy any or all components at the wholesale price they provided.  I was really moved by their help.  They even suggested a charity that might be interested in taking the set.  So clearly I have mixed feelings.

I'm saddened to hear about what you went through with your son. I can't imagine what it would be like to go through that. How cool that good help can even be found in as unlikely a place as GC. Good people show up everywhere. Blessings as you relive tough memories this week.