Hi all,
I'm in the final stages of populating a Pangea vibe. Question on the 26mm Alpha rotaries. Among the two I have for the project, one has a slightly longer shaft than the other. Is it alright to carefully trim those down with a hobby knife or something?
Quote from: Bret608 on August 08, 2016, 01:33:29 PM
Hi all,
I'm in the final stages of populating a Pangea vibe. Question on the 26mm Alpha rotaries. Among the two I have for the project, one has a slightly longer shaft than the other. Is it alright to carefully trim those down with a hobby knife or something?
That's exactly what I did.
I did the same on a Multiplex but one thing you don't want to do is take it off after its mounted, or be extremely careful. I got the bright idea that I could do it after the fact and went to work on it with my oscillating belt sander. Needless to say I unknowingly sanded one of the other pot shafts in the process :o, i.e., crooked knob now.
Thanks to you both! I kind of figured I should do this before soldering those rotaries to the board, which is good because I don't always approach things so reasonably. Anyway, I appreciate the confirmation.
Hey, one more quick question while we're at it...do these rotaries have the same size drill hole as a pot? Had not even thought of that until now...
Quote from: Bret608 on August 08, 2016, 05:47:44 PM
Hey, one more quick question while we're at it...do these rotaries have the same size drill hole as a pot? Had not even thought of that until now...
It's bigger. I use a stepbit, so I don't know what diameter, but definitely bigger.
Be VERY careful when you are trimming the rotary shafts on the Alphas.
To much vibration or excess movement can cause the internals to break. I have had this happen using a knife, a Dremel cutter, and even with large gauge side cutters. After the cut, the violent movement of the shaft caused the rotary to break internally.
Be careful ;)
Duly noted! I will test fit all pots and switches to whatever enclosure I end up with before I decide for sure whether to try this out. I think one of the two rotaries might not really be taller than the usual 16mm Alpha pot shaft.
Quote from: Bret608 on August 08, 2016, 06:39:02 PM
Duly noted! I will test fit all pots and switches to whatever enclosure I end up with before I decide for sure whether to try this out. I think one of the two rotaries might not really be taller than the usual 16mm Alpha pot shaft.
They were for me. :) Taller, that is.
It's not an ideal method but I've shaved them down successfully using a Stanley knife and taking away thin layers.
To trim them down clamp the excess shaft in a vice to cut it down. If you're supporting the switch body and hacking away at the floating shaft much more likely to damage the switch internals.
dave
Quote from: davent on August 09, 2016, 12:44:00 AM
To trim them down clamp the excess shaft in a vice to cut it down. If you're supporting the switch body and hacking away at the floating shaft much more likely to damage the switch internals.
+1
I used this method to cut many Rat Shack pot shafts back in the pre-internet days.
Thanks again everyone! This is why I love this community. :)