I find that the guitar, the pedals and the amp all interact, and it takes experimenting to find the right combo. And, a pedal that's perfect for a Tele and a Marshall can be absolutely horrible with a Les Paul and a Fender Twin.
I would suggest two things. First, start with one guitar straight into one amp, and set the knobs in a way that sounds good to you.
Then add one pedal, and work with the settings on the pedal without changing either your guitar or amp. If you can find settings that you like, mark them on the pedal or write them down. If you can't, set the pedal aside and move on.
Put another pedal alone between your guitar and amp. Same process. Find the sweet settings, or set it aside. Continue until you've tried all your pedals, one at a time.
Second, work on the sequence. Take your two favorite pedals and find a sequence that works, again without changing your guitar or amp. Make notes. If you can't make them work together, set one aside and try another pair. Once the first two are good, add in another pedal, etc.
If you have other guitars or amps, same process with each one.
This should lead you to (1) a set of pedals that work individually and together, and (2) a sequence that gives you sounds that you like.
You will likely find one or more pedals that just don't sound good with the rest of your setup. Use them with a different guitar/amp, or sell them, or give them away.
I would suggest two things. First, start with one guitar straight into one amp, and set the knobs in a way that sounds good to you.
Then add one pedal, and work with the settings on the pedal without changing either your guitar or amp. If you can find settings that you like, mark them on the pedal or write them down. If you can't, set the pedal aside and move on.
Put another pedal alone between your guitar and amp. Same process. Find the sweet settings, or set it aside. Continue until you've tried all your pedals, one at a time.
Second, work on the sequence. Take your two favorite pedals and find a sequence that works, again without changing your guitar or amp. Make notes. If you can't make them work together, set one aside and try another pair. Once the first two are good, add in another pedal, etc.
If you have other guitars or amps, same process with each one.
This should lead you to (1) a set of pedals that work individually and together, and (2) a sequence that gives you sounds that you like.
You will likely find one or more pedals that just don't sound good with the rest of your setup. Use them with a different guitar/amp, or sell them, or give them away.